The witch hazel technique never really worked for me. I'm sensitive to A1 so I want to get it all off. Plus the mone smell wakes me up in my sleep if I can smell it on myself.
This is what I do:
1. Only apply mones to skin with little hair like neck or inside of forearms/wrists. Hair traps the smell and nothing you can do will get it out.
2. Scrub with a hunting soap like "Scent-A-Way". Don't rinse right away, let it sit on your skin for about a minute then rinse.
3. Dampen the area with distilled white vinegar. Rub it in and let it set a minute. It might burn a little. Rinse
4. Finally dampen the area with witch hazel and let soak a minute. Not sure if this step is needed, but why not.
I found this gets off even the stinkiest stickiest mones.