Most complimented fragrances?

[Wezzy]

Hey guys, my first post here. Been on the old Pherotruth for a few weeks before I found out this new one existed!

As above, I'm interested in what colognes/fragrance you've been complimented on the most, particularly by women?

I personally have a sizeable collection of fragrances and always on the lookout for new ones to add.

I stumbled upon pheromones as a result of my fragrance related browsing, and have recently purchased a handful of the 'mainstream' mones (AV, Swoon) and also have BW, THU and OD Testers on the way. I know its a noob move to buy so many but I'm in Europe and have limited suppliers, so have bought testers for now.

I'm interested also in any suggestions for fragrances which might work well with the above, in terms of their vibe and the mones themselves.

My most complimented are:

YSL La Nuite de L'homme
Versace Dylan Blue
Aqua Di Gio Profondo
D&G the One EDP

[CDev77]

The ones you listed are excellent and I get compliments on them. I would also add:

Allure Sport Eau Extreme by Chanel

Dior Home Intense

JPG Le Male Le Parfum (black bottle) 2020

 I get a lot of mentions with this one. It has notes of Cardamom; Iris; creamy Vanilla, Oriental notes and Woodsy Notes.

Versace Pour Homme


R

[Johnny Fever]

I use Fragrantica as a guide to figure out what fragrances to wear during which seasons. I don't know if you'll find it of value or not, but it's helped me somewhat.

[Stride]

Aventus, club de unit intense man, la unit de lhomme, xerjoff naxos, Louis Vuitton L'immensite to name a few

[Wyatt]

YSL La Nuit de L'homme (Women only and they freaking love this scent)
Creed Aventus/Club de Nuit Intense Man (Men and Women about 50/50)
Androtics Akuto (very rarely women)

Nothing else I've worn has ever gotten me compliments.

[Stride]

Rasasi Hawas and Rasasi Hawas Ice are also complimented a lot for me. I prefer Hawas Ice as it's more refined than the Hawas.

[Alcon]

I'm heading to a perfume shop today, but knowing some of the pheromones can come scented, have any of you bought them scented? The choices they have are Cold Water, Aqua Di Gio, Drakkar (I've used that one in the past and really like it!), Musk Cybilla and Vanilla. Thanks! My anniversary is coming up and we're off to Europe for a week, so hence the ask!

[Dsouza]

YSL La Nuit de L'homme (Women only and they freaking love this scent)
Creed Aventus/Club de Nuit Intense Man (Men and Women about 50/50)
Androtics Akuto (very rarely women)

Nothing else I've worn has ever gotten me compliments.

Would you say YSL La Nuit can get better results from women than pheromones?

Are any of your scents lady killers better than any pheromones you used to score ONS?

I'm looking for colognes that are more effective in seduction than pheromones but so far I haven't found any. 

No cologne has defeated L2k 2014 L&S, AM 2014 L&S, M3x 2017 Crash.   

More fcloses with these during my days than anything else.

Edit: just read up on fragrantic on YSL La Nuit ; it supposedly, has the worst longevity ever.  Not one person reported compliments and almost all said its longevity is too short.  Some said 2 hrs.

Which cologne smells identical to or better than AD's Leather and Steel?

[Tuggboat]

I second the blue ones for gals, On the Dior Himme, make sure to get the old one. Chicks seem to like the cardamoms a lot but I don't get attraction as much as just pleasant to be around. The Spices do get a certain audience. Juries out on woods, ouds and gourmands though I have been called a whore on a hard to get gourmand called Hard Candy. kind of a cherry cake, chocolate and oud thing. I don't mind being called a whore.

[Wifflewasser]

Happy by Clinique
Bleu de Chanel
And, believe it or not, Pherlure (many years ago).